I have 25 pens on my desk. I just spent 15 minutes testing them all, one by one, on the back of a discarded invoice. It is a ritual of procrastination, but also a search for something that works as intended. Some are blue, some are black, and at least 5 of them are just empty plastic shells I keep for reasons I cannot adequately explain to my therapist. They feel comfortable in the hand, even if they leave no mark on the page. We do this in marketing, too. We keep tools and strategies that are bone-dry, clicking the retractable tops over and over, hoping that this time, a trace of ink will appear. We are obsessed with the idea that if we hold the pen correctly, the story will write itself according to our outline.
I was sitting in a glass-walled conference room recently, watching a marketing manager named Sarah walk through a flowchart that looked like a map of the London Underground if it had been designed by a paranoid spider. There were 45 distinct nodes. Each one represented a ‘customer state.’ If the lead opened the email but didn’t click, they went to Path B. If they clicked but didn’t book a demo, they were hit with a retargeting ad 35 hours later. It was a masterpiece of logical engineering. Sarah was proud of it, and she should have been. It had taken 15 weeks to build and $2,555 in software integrations to automate.
But while she was explaining the subtle psychological triggers of the Day 15 email, the client we were all courting was actually making his decision. He wasn’t in a funnel. He was in bed, scrolling on his phone at 10:45 PM on a Sunday night because he couldn’t sleep and his primary competitor had just released a new feature that made him feel small. He didn’t wait for the Day 15 email. He didn’t even remember the Day 1 email. He bypassed the beautiful flowchart entirely by texting the CEO of a different firm because he’d seen a helpful video they posted 5 months ago. The system Sarah built was a fortress with no one inside to guard the gate.
The Vending Machine Mentality
We have developed a God complex in the world of B2B sales. We believe that by sheer force of ‘nurturing,’ we can manufacture intent. We think we are orchestrating a journey, but the reality is that the buyer is treating us like a vending machine. They don’t care about the inner workings of the machine. They don’t care how the coil turns or how the temperature is regulated at a constant 35 degrees. They just want the bag of chips when they put the money in. If the machine jams, or if it asks them to fill out a 15-field form before dispensing the snack, they will simply walk to the next machine.
This is the humbling truth of the modern ecosystem. The buyer holds every single card, including several from a different deck that we don’t even know exists. They are doing 75 percent of their research before they ever identify themselves to a seller. They are lurking in Dark Social, talking to peers in Slack groups, and reading reviews on 5 different platforms while we are busy debating whether the ‘Subject Line A’ should have an emoji or a colon. We are optimizing the fringe while the core is moving further away from our control.
The Friction of Mismatched Timing
The friction comes from the mismatch between our timing and theirs. A 15-day drip campaign assumes the buyer’s problem will persist at a steady state of urgency for exactly 15 days. It assumes they won’t have a crisis on Day 4 that requires an immediate solution, and it assumes they won’t lose interest by Day 10. It is a rigid solution for a fluid problem. When I look at the work done by b2b marketing, I see the antidote to this rigidity. They don’t try to trap the buyer in a maze; they build a lighthouse. Inbound marketing isn’t about control; it’s about visibility. It’s about ensuring that when that buyer is scrolling at 11:55 PM, desperate for a solution, you are the one who shows up with the answer, not the one who asks them to wait for a scheduled call on Tuesday.
I’ve made the mistake of over-engineering the ‘experience’ more times than I care to admit. I once spent 5 days tweaking a landing page for a client, convinced that the specific shade of teal on the ‘Submit’ button would be the deciding factor for their $15,000 contract. I was looking at the data, or what I thought was data. In reality, I was looking at a mirror. I was looking at my own need to feel like I was in the driver’s seat. The contract was eventually signed, but not because of the teal button. It was signed because the client’s current provider had missed 5 consecutive deadlines and they were fed up. They didn’t even look at the landing page. They clicked a link in a signature and asked for the invoice.
The Ballpoint Pen of Sales
If you want to understand the buyer, look at the pens on my desk. I have the expensive ones, the $45 fountain pens that require special ink and a specific paper weight. They are the ‘Enterprise Grade’ solutions. And yet, when I need to jot down a phone number in a hurry, I grab the chewed-up ballpoint that I found in the bottom of a laptop bag 5 months ago. Why? Because it’s there. Because it works instantly. Because I don’t have time to be a connoisseur of ink flow when the house is on fire.
Sellers who win are the ones who accept that they are the ballpoint pen. They stop trying to be the grand architect of the buyer’s life and start focusing on being the most accessible, most helpful tool available at the moment of impact. This requires a massive ego shift. It means admitting that your 155-page slide deck might never be read. It means acknowledging that the buyer might spend 15 minutes on your site and make a $105,000 decision without ever talking to a ‘Sales Development Representative.’
Visibility Over Everything
Daniel M.K. told me he doesn’t advertise much. He just keeps his truck clean and parked in visible places. He knows that the graffiti will happen-it’s a certainty of urban life. He doesn’t need to convince people that they have a problem; the neon-green paint on their window does that for him. He just needs to be the person they see when they look for a way out.
We are obsessed with ‘touchpoints,’ but we forget that a touchpoint is only valuable if the person being touched actually wants the contact. Otherwise, it’s just harassment with a better font. The illusion of control is a heavy burden to carry. It makes us rigid. It makes us blame the buyer when they don’t follow our ‘proven’ path. ‘They weren’t a qualified lead,’ we say, when the truth is they were very qualified, just not interested in our 15-step dance.
Strip Away the Clutter
I’m looking at these pens now. I’ve thrown away 5 of the ones that didn’t work. It felt good to clear the clutter. Maybe that’s what we need to do with our marketing funnels. Strip away the nodes that don’t serve the buyer. Stop building mazes and start building bridges. The Sunday night buyer isn’t looking for a journey. They are looking for a result. If you can provide that result in 15 minutes instead of 15 days, you don’t need a flowchart. You just need to be ready.
Focus
Speed
Results
How much of your current strategy is designed to help the buyer, and how much of it is designed to help you feel like you know what’s going to happen next?
